Happy new academic year! Here's a reminder of how automatic grammar-checking software can mangle your work into nonsense, because it's just applying blind rules and heuristics without understanding the meaning. This is an example I found in the wild in a published article, so, to be fair, I don't know that this one was the… Continue reading The G Files Part 5: You Would Lose Clothes
Category: The G Files
The G Files Part 4: The Genuine Article
Articles (a, an and the) are tricky. Non-native English speakers struggle with knowing when and when not to use them. Native speakers instinctively know, but most cannot consciously articulate the rules they're unconsciously following. (Why is it "plants release oxygen into the air" and not "plants release the oxygen into air"? Why is "the tiger… Continue reading The G Files Part 4: The Genuine Article
The G Files Part 3: 10 Failures of Common Sense
As I said in The G Files Part 1, some of the mistakes made by grammar-checking software make syntactic sense but are meaningless or nonsensical in the real world – like Chomsky's famous "Colourless green ideas sleep furiously" sentence. This is because the software knows which words can be nouns, verbs, and so on; but… Continue reading The G Files Part 3: 10 Failures of Common Sense
The G Files Part 2: These are Not the Idioms You’re Looking For
Here are two more examples like the "rise up" and "dark night" examples in The G Files Part 1, where the grammar-checking software thinks it's spotted a phrase that its designers considered poor style, but in fact it's just the same words as would be used in that phrase, but meaning something different in context.… Continue reading The G Files Part 2: These are Not the Idioms You’re Looking For
The G Files Part 1: Why You Shouldn’t Rely on Grammar-Checking Software
A former long-term client wanted me to use grammar-checking software on their documents, in addition to checking them myself – so I've got quite a lot of experience of the way it works, and many of the ways in which it doesn't work. Grammar-checking software works on rules and heuristics. It doesn't understand what it's… Continue reading The G Files Part 1: Why You Shouldn’t Rely on Grammar-Checking Software
